Recently Apple got every nerd on the planet chirping about the ‘ipad’. their new touch pad product, and about for the past three years, kindles, and the future of ebooks have become a popular source of small talk debates, generally a divide between people who get excited over new tech for the sake of new tech and cranky purists who talk about the joys of a good old paperback. Ebooks are also at the root of a debate between a major publishing house, Macmillan and Amazon, where Amazon yanked all the works of the former from their store in a tiff over price fixing.
Another common problem cited with ebooks is DRM, which is a sort of single person liscencing from a product that is a built in self destruct in computer programs, music and other media which limits their use and makes a property vulnerable to suddenly becoming unavailable to the owner when the DRM owning company folds, allow unexpected liscencing yanking and so forth. Understandably this gets people irked. However without protection, all digital media is basically free to copy and share, making piracy extremely easy. For example gigapedia is an enormous search archive of pdfs of books, most of which are still within their copyrights.
I actually don’t mind pdfs that much. Most of my classes’ journal articles are found online through my University’s library, making paper writing an exercise to be conducted in my pajamas. I think ebooks have an important place and are not inherently bad. For example the attempts by the Gutenberg Project are comendable. Classics and out of print lit that would otherwise vanish off the shelves is preserved for free download.
Instead, what concerns me about switching to a new electronic book format is the trashy books. I really like stupid regency novels and historical romances. These are not good books, except that they make me giggle like a hyena on nitrous oxide for the time it takes to consume them. These books are published by the wagon load, formulaic crap that gets dumped into supermarkets and the back shelves of book stores and then forgotten.
I can’t afford to buy these books new; however I get a lot out of second hand shopping and libraries. Lately, living in a big city, I get a lot out of free book heaps When I buy these books second hand, many are outright unreadable or only useable once, so I cycle them back out, leaving them in cafes and Laundromats and other places. I also recycle any other books I’m bored with, from knitting guides to great lit.
Because of the sheer volume of these books I can easily steal enough to feed my reading habit, often nicely formatted into PDFs, but unless I want to actively participate in something illegal, I’m not in a position to pass books along anymore, or participate in bottom feeding from second hand book sales.
I’m also concerned what this will do to text book sales. Regularly updated, specialty books cost an arm and a leg. I understand some of this is evil on the part of publishers and some of it is the nature of the market. Right now, I can survive by buying second hand text books and professors who are lenient enough to permit using past editions, where it’s a new textbook. I am deeply pessimistic about the possibility that this will appreciably lower the cost of text books, just make it hard to get more uses out of your ‘book’.

